Plumbline Faith

Simple Faith, Simple Truth, Simple Virtue

CHURCH AND DISCIPLESHIP: PRECEPTS AND HINDRANCES — May 12, 2025

CHURCH AND DISCIPLESHIP: PRECEPTS AND HINDRANCES

Over the last fifty years – going all the way back to my college days in the mid-1970s – God’s often used me to help relational participatory churches emerge.

Yet I can’t think of a single one of them that didn’t first start with discipleship.

Looking back, I guess that makes sense given that Jesus said He would build His church …

But we are to build disciples.

In contrast, I’ve seen many try to start a “church” first, but in my experience real discipleship seldom follows and things quickly begin falling apart. 

This has been a source of great frustration for many. 

Continue reading →
SCRIPTURAL MANDATES FOR RELATIONAL PARTICIPATORY CHURCH — February 24, 2025

SCRIPTURAL MANDATES FOR RELATIONAL PARTICIPATORY CHURCH

There are numerous New Testament mandates which require that our gatherings as the church be participatory, with ministry one to another out of the diverse gifts God distributes among us.

Unfortunately, however, what we tend to have these days are “mono-churches” that are centered around the monopolizing monologue preaching by the “one” …

Or centered around one particular gift, vision or ministry emphasis.

Instead of mono-churches, here are just some of the New Testament’s many commands about how we are to gather and function together as the multi-part, multi-functional, multi-gifted Body of Christ …

For the mutual edification and building up of each other by one another.

Continue reading →
SIMPLE JOY — May 2, 2016
NO MORE MONO-CHURCH — March 25, 2016

NO MORE MONO-CHURCH

In authentic church, there’s no single ministry or leader around whom everything is organized.

Instead, Scripture says that God bestows diverse gifts and callings among His people …

And that we are to use them to build up each other through ministry one to another – especially when we gather.

That’s why His mission for me should look very different than His mission for you …

And why there’s no mono-church in the New Testament.

“ORGANIC CHURCH” FOLLIES — November 20, 2026

“ORGANIC CHURCH” FOLLIES

If you take seriously the many New Testament imperatives about being the multi-gifted, multi-functional, multi-part Body of Christ, and about gathering together for ministry one to another to mutually build up each other …

Be warned!

Without the anchor of God’s plenary authority through Scripture as His written Word, your gatherings eventually will run adrift and wreck.

I’ve been involved in relational participatory church going back over fifty years, and have never seen an exception.

For example, twenty-five or so years ago there was a vibrant “organic church” movement that we no longer hear much about. Why is that?

It started with lots of energy and enthusiasm, but also lots of naivete. Eventually it started coming under the influence of an approach to Scripture I’ll call hermeneutical existentialism – often without knowing its true source, its checkered history, or even its explicit underlying premises.

That philosophy was developed by Karl Barth – an influential existential “theologian” of the last century who claimed that the actual word of God was some narrative or insight we derive from reading Scripture, rather than Scripture itself.

Essentially, it claimed that our subjective perceptions gleaned from Scripture – either individually or collectively – became more authoritative than God’s actual objective words of Scripture.

it was an approach to Scripture that became very appealing among the organic church community because of the hurt many carried from overbearing Bible thumpers in the highly authoritarian churches they recently had fled.

The movement as a whole became ripe for the picking by those willing to exploit its rightful aversion to past legalistic misuses of Scripture.

Within the organic church community, such exploitation soon arose as Barth’s ideology was popularized – often without being named – by “organic church” writers and self-proclaimed “apostolic workers” like Viola, Rodriquez, Zens and their buddies.

Instead of being transparent about their explicit premises, however, they touted their Barthian agenda under enticing but misleading slogans like:

“Christ is all” (i.e., their perception of Christ transcends all of Scripture and becomes the narrative by which all of Scripture is filtered);

“Deeper life,” (i.e., they have deeper, hidden narratives about God and Christ that supersede Biblical precepts, propositional truths and objective norms);

“Beyond Evangelical” (i.e., who needs the plenary authority of Scripture when you can have a trans-Biblical, personal revelation of Christ – by just buying our books!).

Yet beneath it all, they were explicitly dismissive of the plenary authority of Scripture.

In essence, they wanted to elevate themselves through their own Barthian trans-Biblical narratives as the ones who defined the essentials – and the particulars – for the various churches that came under their influence.

But by their fruit you will know them, and God will not be mocked. As a result, every single church that foolishly listened to them either outright disintegrated or withered away in stagnant irrelevance.

The wreckage they wrought was thorough and astounding …

And eventually destroyed the organic church movement.

Perhaps not surprisingly, when you look under the carnage they created, you also discover that they themselves were never able to successfully or sustainably be part of, start, or maintain any church in their own lives or hometowns like they kept peddling to others.

Talk about the blind leading the blind!

But what should you expect? When someone sets themselves above God Himself and His written Word with some trans-Biblical narrative, God inevitably responds to their narcissistic hubris by tearing it down.

I have a plaque in my study that says “You can either be a wonderful example, or a horrible warning.”

How appropriate!

Let’s learn from the destruction wrought by their foolishness and folly, and resolve to do better as God seeks with this new generation to restore His church to be all that His written Word actually commands and teaches.

As such, our goal is not to “restore” someone’s own narrative about Christ or the early church …

But to embrace what God authoritatively reveals in Scripture about Himself and how He wants us to be His people – one with another.

Only then can we hope to escape the tragic destruction that essentially wiped out the prior “organic church” movement.

IGNATIUS VS THE NEW TESTAMENT — October 24, 2026

IGNATIUS VS THE NEW TESTAMENT

“It is manifest therefore that we should look upon the bishop even as we look upon the Lord himself.” Ignatius, 2nd Century AD. 

Ignatius did more than just about anyone to distort the authoritative teachings of Peter, Paul, John and James, as laid down in the New Testament, about being the authentic Body of Christ – one with another. 

Yet the Roman Catholic “Church” and its self-serving, trans-Biblical institutional structures are built more on his post-Biblical writings than Scripture itself. 

And how about Protestants? They aren’t much better, given that the “reformation” largely ignored church ecclesiology.

In essence, they merely replaced the Pope and his Priests with Denominations and their “Senior Pastors” …

While retaining similar clergy-dominated “services” and hierarchies – although under different titles and formats.

As for me, I think I’ll stick with the authentic Apostles of Scripture and their authoritative Biblical writings …

Than the later writings and man-made traditions of subsequent pundits pushing their own agendas. 

ONE ANOTHER OR MERE COMMODITY? — October 23, 2026

ONE ANOTHER OR MERE COMMODITY?

Is your “church” consuming your God-given gifts and abilities to further its own institutional interests (assuming anyone has stepped off the stage to even really know you) …

Rather than patiently, relationally equipping and releasing you in them for service to Him and others?

Then it’s not a church …

It’s just a business – and you’re a mere commodity.

MONETIZING GOD’S PEOPLE — October 10, 2026

MONETIZING GOD’S PEOPLE

The institutional structure we wrongly call “church” today didn’t emerge until the 4th century – hundreds of years after the New Testament was written.

It arose when men discovered they could monetize God’s people by becoming the focus of ministry from a stage above them …

Instead of unpretentiously serving among them to equip them for ministry.

MALARKEY — September 22, 2026
A VICIOUS TRAP — September 17, 2026

A VICIOUS TRAP

“Churches” these days generally revolve around putting on scripted weekly “services” where marginal (at best) Christians can experience either:

Pseudo-spiritual intensity that feeds their carnality;

A monopolizing monologue that feeds their passivity;

Or both.

Those same “churches” then wonder why their people never grow up to become the multi-gifted, multi-functional, multi-part Body of Christ like the New Testament commands.

It’s a vicious trap.

GOD’S WAYS OR MAN’S WAYS — August 25, 2026

GOD’S WAYS OR MAN’S WAYS

God wants to use us to build HIS ekklesia.

Unfortunately, too many want to use God to build THEIR church instead.

I guess that helps explain why what THEY call “church” today …

Looks nothing like HIS ekklesia of Scripture.

Many have had enough:

Because how can you ever expect to be free of THEIR man-centered schemes …

If you don’t leave and connect with others committed to HIS ways?

——————-

“For am I now seeking the approval of man, or of God? Or am I trying to please man? If I were still trying to please man, I would not be a servant of Christ.” Gal. 1:10

STOLEN CHURCH — August 13, 2026
JESUS GOES TO “CHURCH” — July 23, 2026
BOUNDARIES — June 12, 2026
NEW WINE — June 9, 2026

NEW WINE

After 300 years, New Testament mandates about being the multi-gifted, multi-functional, multi-part Body of Christ that builds up each other by gathering for ministry one to another …

Morphed in the 4th Century into pastor-centric, podium-focused institutional “services” with spectator seating that we now mistakenly call “church.”

So tell me again how you’re gonna suddenly fix that entrenched, post-Biblical, man-made system???

——————

As Jesus said, speaking of the tradition-bound religious folk of His day:

“You will be ever hearing but never understanding; you will be ever seeing but never perceiving. For this people’s heart has become calloused; they hardly hear with their ears, and they have closed their eyes …” Matthew 13:14–15 (citing Isaiah 6:9–10)

“And no one pours new wine into old wineskins. Otherwise, the new wine will burst the skins; the wine will run out and the wineskins will be ruined… And no one after drinking old wine wants the new, for they say, ‘The old is better.’” Luke 5:37–39

FINDING EKKLESIA — June 3, 2026

FINDING EKKLESIA

If we’re not willing to truly give to the Lord our hurts, regrets, agendas and non-essential pet doctrines that have come to define us …

We’ll never truly succeed at finding, starting or experiencing relational participatory church.

You know:

A community of believers who gather for ministry one to another as they mutually build up each other through love and the many diverse gifts God distributes among us …

Just like the New Testament commands.

Instead, it will be impossible to truly submit to one another or prefer each other above ourselves …

Because we’ll remain stuck with ourselves.

—————————

“Humble yourselves, therefore, under God’s mighty hand, that he may lift you up in due time. Cast all your anxiety on him because he cares for you.” 1 Peter 5:6-7

NEW PASTURES — May 31, 2026

NEW PASTURES

I’ll never forget going to jail years ago to visit a dozen men who had become one of many relational participatory churches that some of us helped start there.

For several months, we had poured our lives out for them through intense discipleship.

Most were brand-new believers, and from those efforts a church had emerged in their housing unit.

This time, as I joined them, I sat quietly and watched as they gathered and engaged in powerful ministry to one another, just like we had taught them.

After nearly two hours, they suddenly stopped, saying that after all I had done for them they had decided earlier that week to do something for me.

Continue reading →
DENYING GOD’S SOVEREIGNTY — May 20, 2026

DENYING GOD’S SOVEREIGNTY

God has the unfettered right and ability to do whatever He wants.

But it is a non sequitur to then fall into the trap of Calvinistic determinism.

Because God also has the right and ability to grant us the option – as we see throughout Scripture – to reject Him and His will.

To say otherwise is to diminish, rather than affirm, His ultimate sovereignty …

Which is the ultimate irony of Calvinism.

OUT OF EGYPT — April 7, 2026
THE MORPHOLOGY OF SERMONS — March 28, 2026

THE MORPHOLOGY OF SERMONS

Did you know that our English word “sermon” originated from the Latin word “sermo,” meaning “conversation or discourse.”

In Classical Latin, sermo applied to common speech, or “the way people talk” with each other.

Hmmm …

Over time, it morphed into weekly staged, monopolizing, monologue lectures by a professional, institutional class of churchmen called “clergy” who arose in the 4th Century.

Unfortunately, they quickly corrupted not only our words, but so much more, by switching the New Testament focus from relational participatory gatherings for ministry to one another …

To scripted, spectator “church services” that focus on them.

Continue reading →
SPECTATOR MONO-CHURCH? — March 26, 2026

SPECTATOR MONO-CHURCH?

What’s left when you give up the “sanctuary” with its spectator seating …

The “senior pastor” with his elevated pulpit and weekly monopolizing monologue “sermons” …

And the “worship” team with their staged performances?

Perhaps, just perhaps, God willing …

The beginning of church as the New Testament actually defines it.

BY FAITH ALONE — March 24, 2026

BY FAITH ALONE

When I hear someone say “by faith alone,” I sometimes ask them to define what faith is. Often, they’re stumped and can’t give a cogent answer.

Although it includes the concepts of “believing” and “trusting,” if you study the Greek word for faith in the New Testament, it ultimately means to believe and trust someone or something by giving them our faithful allegiance.

So “putting our faith in Christ” is far more than what we feel, think, or believe.

It’s also our loyalties …

And how we act in fidelity to them.

When I took the time to study this decades ago, it changed my whole theological framework.

It also finally resolved so many theological debates that revolve around oft-repeated slogans …

Without understanding the underlying words as Scripture actually meant them.

DISCIPLESHIP — March 13, 2026
CHURCH AND RELIGION — March 2, 2026
PULPIT DISCONNECTS — February 27, 2026

PULPIT DISCONNECTS

IRONY:

Monopolizing monologue “sermons” – on topics like “Community” and being a “Church Family” and “Using Your Spiritual Gifts” – from behind a pulpit on an elevated stage looking down on passive attendees organized into row after row of spectator seating.

SENIOR PASTORS IN THE NEW TESTAMENT — February 16, 2026

SENIOR PASTORS IN THE NEW TESTAMENT

Some claim there are no “Senior Pastors” in the New Testament.

They’re wrong.

It’s right there, in black and white, plain to see:

As John noted, Diotrephes was first in his church and preeminent over everyone else, with all ministry and authority revolving around him. (3 John 1:9-10)

Clearly, then, he was a Senior Pastor – just like we have today.

So it must be Biblical!

I bet if I keep looking, I’ll find lots of other examples of Senior Pastors in the New Testament.

I mean, they must be there, right?

After all, how can any church operate without one?

Looking, looking, looking …

TRUE ELDERS — February 13, 2026

TRUE ELDERS

Until your mentality about leadership shifts from “ruling over” others through command and control rooted in hierarchy and titles …

To being a resource “serving” others through experience and relationships rooted in community and earned respect …

You will never “get” relational participatory church like the New Testament teaches.

You know:

With ministry one to another for the mutual building up of each other through the many diverse gifts God distributes among us …

Rather than some mono-church centered around you and your own vision and gifts.

Plus you’ll become a bottleneck …

Rather than humbly equipping others to exceed you in the multi-gifted, multi-functional, multi-part Body of Christ.

Continue reading →
HOUSE CHURCH FAKERY — February 3, 2026

HOUSE CHURCH FAKERY

House churches?

My observation fifteen years ago was that 90% of those writing books about them …

Never bothered to first make one work in their own lives and hometowns.

They seemed more interested in the notoriety of promoting their own concepts of relational participatory gatherings …

Than actually learning to sustainably do it.

Continue reading →
NOT THE CHURCH — January 27, 2026

NOT THE CHURCH

The building is not the church.

The stage and the spectator seats are not the church.

The “worship service” is not the church.

The preacher and his pulpit are not the church.

But we – yes we – might actually become the church …

When we start gathering to mutually build up each other through ministry one to another.

You know, like the New Testament explicitly says.

Do this …

And all that other stuff becomes just a distraction.